News & Reviews Indian Ocean Mauritius Four Seasons Mauritius vs One&Only Le Saint Géran

Picking the best luxury hotel in Mauritius is like that South Park episode: Giant Douche versus Turd Sandwich.  It’s a battle no one wins, and in this case the no-one’s are One&Only Le Saint Géran and Four Seasons Resort Mauritius at Anahita.  The former, the island’s first luxury hotel; the latter, recently reopened after a major refurbishment.  Two of the biggest names here, on the same stretch of the east coast, and I did them back-to-back with two children in tow.  So if you’re unlucky enough to end up here, presumably only because you were in a Cast Away-style plane crash, and have to pick one, here’s how they compare.

Setting

One&Only has a beach, so I think we can declare this the winner.  Ok, so Four Seasons has a beach, but it’s the same way that I have the looks of Leonardo DiCaprio, in that we both have faces….and that’s the end of it.  It’s not a pleasant place to be, not only from the coarse sand, nor because of all the warning signs about animals trying to murder you, but the vibe of it is more St Tropez…right after a nuclear attack.  They have a better beach, but it’s a 20-minute boat ride away.  As a general rule, travelling 20 minutes to a beach while at a beach resort is rarely a good sign.

One&Only sits on its own peninsula, with the open ocean on one side and a sheltered lagoon on the other.  The water is flat, calm and good for children.  The beach ain’t no Seychelles, but it’s also no Four Seasons, and last I checked, that is a deciding factor in this debate.  It stretches for miles and, sure, there are rocks right when you want to get in, but who really wants to get in the ocean?  Oh, you do.  Shame.  There’s always another bit of land out there across the bay, so you’re never quite staring into the abyss, and instead a wind farm.

Four Seasons is built around its barachois, the old saltwater fish ponds, and the lobby looking out over them is pretty stunning.  It feels more like swampland, with style.  It’s a busier spot, though, with more boats going past.  And did I mention that beach?

Winner: One&Only.

Service

One&Only is slow.  Slow at meals, slow at turndown, and somehow slower on departure.  The staff are warm, kind and lovely.  They are also in no hurry whatsoever.

Four Seasons is quicker, and manages to be worse, but somehow still preferable.  There’s an app, staffed by people programmed to reply “Certainly” and “Someone will be with you soon.” My printer offers more service.  But my printer has never given me wrong opening times and directions, like they did.  Nor made me ask repeatedly for bikes, get told it’s done, and then each time discover that bikes must be a construct of the mind in Mauritius.

Winner: Can both teams lose?

Food

One&Only ruined breakfast, my favourite meal of the day.  There is no coming back from that.  I won’t even give them a chance of a rebuttal by mentioning where else we ate.

Four Seasons is a lottery.  Awase, the Japanese, was surprisingly great, and the coconut brioche at breakfast was special.  Radici was hit and miss.  The breakfast buffet is still mediocre, but it’s calmer and comes with actual table service.

Winner: Four Seasons.  Inconsistent beats consistently disappointing.

Accommodation

One&Only’s Beachfront Suite is generous inside.  But the rooms are stacked in two-storey blocks, so you get neighbours beside you and above you, terraces close enough to share, and “beachfront” means near the beach.  Ours came with thumping music and a bathroom that smelled of sewage.

Four Seasons’ rooms are much better, and well suited to families, with a decent, mostly private terrace that’s the best part of the whole thing.  The catch is location.  Pick one near the middle, or spend your week waiting for buggies.

Winner: Four Seasons, comfortably.

Facilities

One&Only’s major strength.  Tennis, padel, mini golf, basketball, motorised water sports, and the kids and teen clubs, all clustered in one lively hub.  There are also three shops, one of them a Brunello Cucinelli, for anyone who needs cashmere on a beach.  Look closely and the maintenance slips: courts under repair, wires hanging near the pools, a dismal splash area.

Four Seasons has its own beach on the island Ile aux Chats, a stunning main area filled with restaurants and a Rum Library tempting enough to interest this non-drinker, free ice cream, and a kids club open 8.30 am to 8.30 pm.  The main pool area, however, feels like it was washed up on the beach.

Winner: One&Only.

Spa & Gym

Both gyms are excellent.  One&Only’s is split across three spaces covering strength, cardio, spinning and Pilates.

The Guerlain spa at One&Only has a beautiful entrance and a properly heated outdoor pool, along with missing sauna lights and stained cushions.  Four Seasons’ Oseyan spa is the more striking, with treatment suites on stilts over the mangroves and a thermal suite with sauna, steam, cold plunge and experience showers.  As with every spa, walk it, admire it, and think hard before paying for a treatment.

Winner: Four Seasons.

Kids

One&Only delivers for families.  The kids club runs 9 am to 10 pm, there’s a party every night at 8 pm, and under-fives eat free.  It’s split by age: a Family Room for 0–3s, the main club from three, and TweensOnly for 8–12s, which for some reason shares a wall with the servers.  Outside there’s a trampoline, sandpit and climbing frame, plus a splash area that may be the worst I’ve ever seen.  The calm lagoon helps too.  My children, however, ignored all of it for the ducks.

Four Seasons’ kids club is large, open 8.30 am to 8.30 pm, and thoroughly undesirable-looking, redeemed almost entirely by a shaded, swimmable pool at its centre.  The arts and crafts room has an enormous television and a games console in it, which rather undermines the arts and the crafts.  The teens club is better, and was deadly quiet.  There’s a pancake station and free ice cream at the pool.

Winner: One&Only.

Overall

No matter how much better the One&Only beach may be, there’s no way I would pick it over Four Seasons.  Life is a compromise.  Sometimes it’s compromising on only eating that third Five Guys of the day; other times it’s accepting that the beach is rubbish, but at least the bathroom doesn’t smell of sewage.

Nothing about One&Only is exceptional.  I wouldn’t go back.  Four Seasons does everything it controls well and everything it inherited badly.  I wouldn’t go back.  But, I could handle returning.

If you must do Mauritius, do the Four Seasons, although if you’re really keen on listening to what I have to say: skip the island altogether.

  • Looking to
    book a trip?

    If you’re looking to book a trip, then get in touch. We would be delighted to plan your dream holiday.

    Book With Dorsia

  • Want to
    chat to us?

    We’re known for our brutally honest reviews – we’d love to hear about your experiences too.

    Contact us

  • Want to
    chat to others?

    Come and join the discussion with others over on Reddit and be part of our community.

    Join us on Reddit

Why Travel With Us?

  • We Get You

    As members of the same privileged communities we serve, we know what it takes to deliver extraordinary experiences.

  • Connections Count

    Dorsia Travel is always up to speed on the best places to go - and the agency’s clients are always assured the warmest of VIP welcomes.

  • Hands-on and Honest

    We deliver expert recommendations and guidance with unwavering honesty so you can enjoy the best experience with your friends and family.

Your Journey Begins Here

While every trip is fully bespoke and completely unique, Dorsia Travel doesn’t charge its clients fees; trips typically start at US$2,500 per person per day.

Contact Us

Tom Cahalan

Written by Tom Cahalan on 8th Oct '26

Tom is the co-founder of Dorsia Travel, a luxury travel writer, a safari addict, and a professional complainer.

More About Tom