News & Reviews Indian Ocean Madagascar Review: Miavana, Madagascar (2024)

2024 feels like my comeback tour—think Oasis, but in the far more glamorous world of blogging.  It’s more like a redemption tour, revisiting some of my biggest disappointments, starting with Miavana, a place where I probably left one of my biggest marks.  My 2017 review still tops Google searches—and likely tops the list of reviews that crushed their souls.  I loved parts and absolutely despised others.  Ultimately, they launched far too soon, burdened with far too many issues.

But that was seven years ago.  Back then, I visited with my then-girlfriend, who’s now my wife.  I’ve grown—not necessarily grown-up, but grown in the sense that I now have more hair in my ears and nose.  It felt like the right time to give Miavana another shot.

But Miavana remains as challenging to reach as ever.  If the flights don’t deter you, a cyclone just might.  We planned to return in June, only for a cyclone to shut the property down, delaying our trip.  After four months of closure, we finally made it back as some of the first guests to return.  I could sense their deep determination to get everything right this time.  And you know what?  In almost every case, they did.

Getting There

I usually don’t bother dedicating a section to how to get somewhere, but for those of us who don’t have a private jet, Miavana is still an absolute pain in the arse to reach.  Sure, it’s a bit easier than it was during my last stay, but that’s like saying pulling your teeth out with pliers is better now because the pliers are gold-plated.

We flew from London via Addis Ababa to Nosy Be.  From there, it should’ve been a smooth hour-long helicopter ride to Miavana. But, of course, that’s not what happened.  Addis Ababa was hit by this toxic entity called rain—the kind we in England call a “pleasant summer’s day,” where you invite your friends over for a BBQ—but apparently, it was enough to divert every plane to Jeddah instead.

So, we spent three hours in Jeddah, then finally headed back to Addis, only to abort the landing, circle around aimlessly, and eventually land six hours late.  After that, we sat around waiting for any scrap of information, finally boarded the plane, and then spent three more hours sitting there before we took off.  Philip Schofield was on board, and he went full animal mode—kicking, screaming, and had to be tasered.  None of that actually happened, but hey, I need the clicks.

Of course, none of this is Miavana’s fault, but you can’t prove a negative, so who’s to say it wasn’t their fault?

What they were responsible for was setting up a WhatsApp group to help sort out our very, very delayed arrival, and being awesome at taking care of us.  By the time we landed, they’d arranged an overnight hotel, a driver, and the helicopter transfer for the next morning.  The kind of hotel that makes you wonder what all the fuss is about with those Russian penal colonies—surely they can’t be worse than this?  But hey, it had a helipad, which I can only assume was there so guests could be medevacked to a nearby puppy farm so their soul could be restored.  In other words, it provided a bed for the night.

We also had a VIP arrival service to navigate the ridiculous number of passport and security checks, which seems to employ 19 people to do one job.  It’s like you’re trying to get a meeting with Hannibal Lector.  This was a big improvement from last time when you were left to wrestle with Madagascar’s endless bureaucracy on your own.  Now, someone handles it for you while you stand there in disbelief.

The next morning, we were picked up from the hotel’s helipad in Miavana’s brand-new helicopter and enjoyed a 45-minute ride to the property.  Immediately, we were greeted by the management and our two butlers and taken back to our room in a Tuk Tuk.

Setting

It doesn’t take long to appreciate the stunning natural beauty of Madagascar.  The helicopter ride feels like passing through every landscape on Earth—rivers, dry dusty plains, lush green fields, oceans, mountains, and I was half expecting to see an iceberg.  And of course, there’s plenty of beautiful, glimmering ocean—along with humpback whales, manta rays, turtles, and that piece of plastic you didn’t recycle twenty years ago.  Shame on you.

It feels like one of the most remote places on earth, where you barely see any signs of human civilization until you reach the island.  Miavana is now, accurately, not calling itself a private island.  The island is home to three villages and spans around 10 square kilometres.  But it’s okay that it’s not private.  In fact, the size and the opportunity to visit nearby villages add to its charm, setting it apart from the Maldives by offering a more authentic experience.

The natural environment remains largely untouched by modern development.  Well, apart from the super luxury resort on the island.  The island’s landscape is a mix of pristine beaches, dense forests, and vibrant coral reefs.  The coastline is lined with soft, white sand that meets the clear, turquoise waters of the Indian Ocean.  The ocean here is calm and inviting, with shallow waters that gradually deepen, creating a perfect setting for marine life to thrive.

Beyond the beaches, the island is covered with lush vegetation.  Tall palm trees sway gently in the breeze, and the undergrowth is rich with native plants, offering a habitat for various bird species and the newly introduced lemurs.

The beach is an absolute delight.  The sand is so soft it feels it will make you feel all warm and fuzzy, like walking on the shattered dreams of your enemies.  Just don’t get too attached to that idea when the wind kicks in, or you might find that soft sand taking up residence in places it definitely doesn’t belong.

They did pre-warn me that it was the windy season and the maths checks out.  I was previously here at almost the exact time of year and it was fine, but this time mother nature took things personal.  The breeze here isn’t just a gentle whisper; it’s more like nature’s own wind machine set on high.  Somehow, it doesn’t stop the mosquitos.  They’re here too, defying all logic and aerodynamics by thriving even in this windstorm.  You’d think they’d get blown away and focus on survival, but no, their relentless, Terminator-esq pursuit of me was more important.

Facilities

The heart of Miavana is the Piazza, an impressive structure of wood, stone and water that houses most of the resort’s facilities.  I still admire the design.  It’s understated in some ways, not overly flashy, yet the striking turquoise accents, clever use of water features, and exceptional stonework make it stand out.

Outside, you’ll find the boma, a large pool, and dining tables scattered along the beach.  There’s a shaded lounge area and additional dining spots, along with a bar that features a rooftop viewing area.  Indoors, you’ll discover a wine cellar, museum, boutique, lounge, and dining room.

This is the spot where, if you don’t feel like lounging in your enormous private villa, you can hang out.  We would have spent more time here if the wind hadn’t been trying to murder me.  We managed to have breakfast by the beach on the one and only calm day, while on the other days, we alternated between indoor and covered areas, depending how much of a dick the wind was being.

The other main hub is the activity center, where you’ll find non-motorized watersports like paddleboards, kayaks, and more.  It’s also the starting point for many activities and excursions, such as fishing trips.  Next to it is the gym, which boasts full bifold doors that swing open to let in the sound of the ocean during your workout.  And trust me, you’ll need all the motivation you can get because the gym is looking a bit sparse.  Equipment-wise, it’s like your dad’s garage sale: the treadmill’s out of commission, leaving you with a rower (which felt like it might snap—the chain came off twice in two minutes), a multi-fitness machine, one bike, some dumbbells, and a boxing bag.

If motorised watersports are more your speed, it’s just a short trip to a nearby cove.  Currently, there’s nothing much there, but they still offer the same beach picnic I enjoyed last time.  There are plans to add a restaurant in the future, with the foundations already in place.

There’s still no official spa here—though they now admit it.  Treatments are offered in-room or around the island, and they’ve technically converted a villa for spa use, but it’s still out of order.  They do have three full-time therapists, though, so you’re covered.

They set up the spa treatment in our villa.  The experience itself is lovely—foot rub, a choice of scents, and some deep breathing to start.  The only hiccup?  I was lying face down, ready to relax, when the therapist suddenly remembered I hadn’t filled out the form and asked me to do it right then.  After signing something that probably prohibits me from saying anything negative about them ever again, I received a great treatment.  At the end of the treatment they brought over tea and fruit platter.  This is where all-inclusive really wins and properties get a chance to shine.

What else?  Oh yes, they now use Starlink and the Internet is actually usable.  To the extent we were streaming football matches without any problems at all and I didn’t want to strangle myself to death.  I really do need to emphasise that last time I was here the only way to send an email was to wake up between 2 and 4am as the internet was like a vampire with a very laid back work ethic.

Room

All 14 villas at Miavana are just meters from the beach, spread along one stretch of the island.  While the villas are largely the same, with variations in the number of bedrooms, some are closer to the beach whilst others offer more privacy.

We were given the same villa as last time—Villa 2, a two-bedroom at the end of the island.  To the right is Villa 1, one of the most private spots since there’s little reason for anyone to pass by, unless they’re headed to the epic sandbank that appears during low tide.

The villas are tucked away at the end of a long, winding road, offering complete privacy.  Each villa comes with bikes and a buggy to navigate the area, and the entrance is so secluded by shrubs and bushes that you can’t see the front at all.  There’s a hut for parking the buggy and bikes and then beyond more shrugs is the entrance.  The villa is still much as it was previously, with the addition of some doors in preparation for air conditioning.   It still retains its stunning appeal, especially with the use of that beautiful turquoise blue.  It’s hard to find much to complain about here.

But I will try.

The design allows for plenty of airflow, making the space feel airy and open, which is great—except during the windy season.  It feels like a major design flaw that the rooms are this airy.  There’s no way to shut out the wind completely—not yet, at least—and even in the room, the wind is relentless.  They offer kite surfing as an activity, so I’m fairly sure they know how strong the winds can get.  It’s not that warm in the mornings, and one night I actually found it cold, even under the duvet.  One of the umbrellas was ripped, some tiles came off the roof, and another umbrella toppled over in the wind.  The wind even flows through the toilet area, making it feel like you might not even need to wipe.

Unfortunately, the first night’s sleep was terrible.  Despite having the nets up, I could hear mosquitoes buzzing around my ear and woke up looking like the Beast after a botched plastic surgery, complete with a shellfish allergy.

Alright, so two complaints.  But beyond that, the room is a masterpiece.  It’s incredibly spacious, bathed in natural light, with a beautiful design that exudes character and an abundance of amenities.  Large bifold doors surround the room, inviting the outside in and creating such a welcoming environment that leaving to do anything else feels excessive.  It’s extremely private, with just the right distance to the beach separating you from the masses of…well, no one.  You’ll likely never see anyone.

You enter into the living and dining area, where a large curved turquoise sofa faces the TV and ottoman, and a massive dining table is laden with snacks—you definitely won’t go hungry here.  The kitchen is well-stocked – whether that’s the fridge, wine cooler or ice maker.  There’s an additional room that can double as a study and bedroom, so bringing young kids along is perfectly possible even in a one-bedroom villa.  This room has an additional bathroom with a luggage area, shower, and toilet.

In the main bedroom, there’s a small desk area tucked in the corner, with a luggage area behind the bed to keep things tidy.  The bathroom features a huge, sunken bath, double vanity with sinks on either side, and doors that open straight to the beach and an enclosed outdoor shower.  The shower and toilet are separated only by sheets, which, in the high winds, constantly blow around, making the space feel too exposed, even when you’re by yourself.

Outside, you’ll find a dining table, plenty of sun loungers, and ample shade.  The veranda opens up to the pool and beach access.  The long grass provides a natural barrier from the beach, adding to the villa’s sense of privacy.  The pool, though not heated, seems larger than I remember, though it’s still more suited for a refreshing plunge than for swimming laps.

Activities

Listing all the activities would be longer than this already overly long review, so let’s just say there’s plenty to keep you busy.  For me, the highlight was supposed to be filming the humpback whales, which were everywhere last year.  But guess who decided not to show up this time?  Still, we did spot one with a calf.  We also saw plenty of manta rays, which was really special, even from the helicopter.  Typical—here I am, with unlimited freedom to fly my drone since there were no other guests to bother, and it’s too windy to use it.

Lemurs have recently been introduced to the island, and the team will track them down and let you know when they’ve found them.  Twice I went to see them, and twice they were hanging out in the garden of Villa #3, just a few hundred meters from our room.  Excellent service, Mr. and Mrs. Lemur.  We also took the helicopter for two other excursions to see lemurs in their more natural habitat.  The first experience was incredible—the lemurs came so close we could have petted them.  Then we returned to the spot where I saw black lemurs during my 2017 visit, but they clearly didn’t remember our amazing time together as they didn’t even come say hello.  Despite both of these trips being some of the rare activities you have to pay extra for, I’d highly recommend them.

There’s a dedicated area for motorised water sports like water skiing and tubing, and you can also explore the island on quad bikes.  If windsurfing is your thing, you’re in for a treat—this place is practically made for it.  Snorkelling and diving are also options, but did I mention the wind?  I tried the nature walk again, only to discover that the “nature” part is still missing.  Ironically, after searching high and low for a chameleon, we found one right outside my villa after the walk was over.

Service

It’s rare to experience world-class service even before you arrive, but Miavana truly showed its colours by stepping in and seamlessly ensuring we had a place to stay that first night.  This exceptional service continued throughout our entire stay.  Every detail on the stay list was taken care of, right down to remembering my sweet tooth from the last visit.  They even went the extra mile, importing food and drink from the UK.

The butlers were amazing, the activities staff superb, and the helicopter pilots—who skilfully avoided flying us into a mountain—definitely my favourites.  The staff were always attentive, coming to us before we ever needed to seek them out, and they made our experience special with thoughtful touches, like setting up breakfast on the beach.

However, as nitpicking is my thing, let me pick the nit.  Despite ordering the same drink every day, we always had to ask for it.  I also asked about Greek yoghurt, which they didn’t have, and waited to see if they’d get it without a reminder—but they didn’t.  And it shouldn’t require us to ask for more and more anti-fly devices, when even Stevie Wonder could see how bad it was.  Overall, mostly epic, but the service could have been a bit sharper once we stepped in the restaurant.

There is such a strong focus on excellent service here.

Food

The food experience was generally delightful.

Lunch featured a daily-changing selection of tapas options, alongside a regular choice of freshly made pizzas from their pizza oven.  Dinner offered three options per course, with small, well-balanced portions that I appreciated.  The menu was rich in local flavours, adding to the variety and excitement of discovering something new each day.  A lot of the food was restaurant quality, to the point I would want to order more of it.  The pizzas were also a highlight, especially the one with pineapple, burning chili, and bacon.

Then we have the pastries.  Give that pastry chef a pay rise.  For breakfast, the pastries would change daily, for lunchtime it was hard to know what to pick, so I took one for the team, ensured this review was thorough and ate all of it.  Every afternoon, a new cake was delivered to our room.  All of it, superb.

On our final night, they hosted a Malagasy-themed evening.  I loved the irony that only the local cuisine managed to disappoint.  Whatever that “banana” was, it will haunt me for a long time.

Breakfast featured a comprehensive à la carte menu with some intriguing options like foie gras, which was a surprising but welcome addition to the morning lineup.  Naturally, it was the one thing they didn’t have available that day.  When it finally reappeared on the menu, another key ingredient was missing.  If I’d kept ordering it throughout my stay, I might have been able to piece together the full dish on my own.

Kids friendly

Normally I can answer this with more authority as my spawn comes with me, but in this case I was just with my Dad and whilst he still acts as a child, and is a few years away from needing his arse wiped, I cannot be sure of the answer here.  There is no kids club for a start, which is never a good sign—this place is more about adventure than arts and crafts.  But kids under 14 stay free, so that’s definitely friendly towards kids.  They do offer babysitting too, but it’s more throwing together guest relations and butlers to help out.  I’d love to see how they get on if you ask them to look after your kids 24/7.  There’s also kids’ dining menus, and activity guides just for the youngest guides, so it’s certainly not a lost cause, but I would think it’s most interesting for over fives.

Getting out of there

The heli touched down at Nosy Be, revealing an airport that didn’t have a single plane in sight.  What followed was sheer chaos, with hectic queues and an army of people checking our passports, all while operating on a system designed by the Joker.  They should have someone there to help you navigate the madness, especially since English seemed to be a foreign concept.  Which it is.

After an absurd amount of form-filling, we passed through the single gate into a large, un-airconditioned waiting hall, where we sat for two hours, slowly melting.  The arrival experience had improved significantly, but the departure was still chaotic.  Don’t expect your trip to end on a luxurious note—unless, of course, you have a private jet, in which case, enjoy your perfect life.

The Good

  • Villas
  • Service

The Bad

  • The wind
  • Getting there and getting out of there

The Luxurious

  • Setting
  • Butler service
  • Food
  • Activities
  • Lemurs
  • Privacy and exclusivity

Conclusion

Miavana has undergone an evolution, not revolution.  It hasn’t undergone a massive transformation – it never needed to – it has addressed the issues that needed fixing, and that was always enough to make it worth a visit.  Having just reopened after a four-month closure, everyone was clearly anxious about making mistakes and ending up on this blog, but they delivered an excellent experience.  The property is incredibly exclusive and beautifully maintained, with stunning beaches, excellent activities, superb food, and very attentive service.  The villas are simply beautiful; I tried to think if I’ve stayed in a better one-bedroom villa, and only Kisawa comes close.  The excursions were great, and if you love nature, you are surrounded by incredible diversity.  My dad, who’s about to turn 70, was zipping around on quad bikes and jet skis, and I’m pretty sure he was eyeing the helicopter at one point.  There’s been a clear investment in the property—a new helicopter, new boats, lemurs, and you know, things that work, which should work.

That said, the rooms’ inability to handle the wind—without making it sound like there’s a hurricane between your eyeballs—needs some serious attention.  They’re installing air conditioning this month, and it’s not just talk—they’ve already added glass around the bedroom.  While this won’t completely banish the wind (you’ll still feel it whipping around in other rooms), it’s a step in the right direction.  Honestly, after seven years, they should’ve cracked the wind problem by now.  Yes, it was unusually windy during my stay (apparently, August and September are prime wind months), but that didn’t make it any less annoying.  Fix that and they get a higher rating.

Seven years ago, I said Madagascar needed Miavana to not only survive, but thrive so that other companies consider entering the market.  In that time, the only new entrant is Miavana’s parent company, Time+Tide, with a reflagging of an existing property.  So, would I have liked a few things to be better?  Sure.  But Miavana is so far beyond anything else in this country that it’s more surprising how much they get right rather than the minor things that go wrong.

Miavana has not reinvented itself, it’s perfected what it already had, making it a top-tier destination and a welcome member of the ultra-luxury, all-inclusive island club.

Dorsia Rating:

4/5

What's this mean?

  • Looking to
    book a trip?

    If you’re looking to book a trip, then get in touch. We would be delighted to plan your dream holiday.

    Book With Dorsia

  • Want to
    chat to us?

    We’re known for our brutally honest reviews – we’d love to hear about your experiences too.

    Contact us

  • Want to
    chat to others?

    Come and join the discussion with others over on Reddit and be part of our community.

    Join us on Reddit

In Summary

  • Rates

    Rooms start from $3,700 per person per night

  • What else?

    We were the only guests for the first two days—three if we had arrived on time. It's a lot like Laucala in that sense; it’s not a place where you’ll bump into a crowd. It’s certainly not for the party animal types—more for those who have seen all the animals sleeping on their safari and think, "That looks the life for me".  But then the activities are so numerous that you'll have plenty to do, should you decide.  

Why Travel With Us?

  • We Get You

    As members of the same privileged communities we serve, we know what it takes to deliver extraordinary experiences.

  • Connections Count

    Dorsia Travel is always up to speed on the best places to go - and the agency’s clients are always assured the warmest of VIP welcomes.

  • Hands-on and Honest

    We deliver expert recommendations and guidance with unwavering honesty so you can enjoy the best experience with your friends and family.

Your Journey Begins Here

While every trip is fully bespoke and completely unique, Dorsia Travel doesn’t charge its clients fees; trips typically start at US$2,500 per person per day.

Contact Us

Tom Cahalan

Written by Tom Cahalan on 2nd Sep '24

Tom is the co-founder of Dorsia Travel, a luxury travel writer, a safari addict, and a professional complainer.

More About Tom